myNavyRates.rg
Home/Head-to-Head/ST vs STG
Donate
Compare All RatesBest ListsQuizPayBonusesASVAB CalculatorAdvancement Name SearchDuty StationsFamily ImpactFree DegreeRecruitersBe an OfficerArticlesFAQs
myNavyRates.rg
Donate
All Rates/Head-to-Head
ST
Sonar Technician
VS
STG
Sonar Technician Surface
ST
Sonar Technician edges out
5.3 vs 4.9 overall score
  • •Choose STG if you want faster promotions.
  • •Choose ST if civilian career value matters most.
  • •Choose STG for higher total compensation (bonus + pay).
  • •ST is more undermanned — potentially faster advancement.
CategorySTSTG
Overall Score5.34.9
Enlistment BonusNone$25,000
Civilian Salary$55K–$90K$50K–$78K
Promotion Score4.67.0
Lifestyle Score5.05.0
Civilian ROI4.63.4
Manning %83%111%
Clearancesecretsecret
Communitysurfacesurface
View full ST profileView full STG profileFull comparison table

More head-to-head matchups

Other Navy rate comparisons featuring ST, STG, and similar communities.

  • CWT vs IT
  • CT vs IT
  • EM vs ET
  • HM vs IT
  • ABH vs BM
  • AE vs AT

Best lists worth a look

  • Highest Paying Navy Jobs
  • Highest Enlistment Bonuses
  • Fastest-Promoting Rates
  • Best for Civilian Life
  • Rates Requiring Clearance
  • Best Quality of Life

Related reading

  • How to Choose a Navy Rate
  • What ASVAB Scores Do You Need?
  • How to Work with a Navy Recruiter
  • Recruiter vs. MEPS Classifier
  • How Navy Promotion Works
  • Shore Duty vs. Sea Duty

Explore

  • All Rates
  • Side-by-Side
  • Best Lists
  • Articles
  • FAQs

Tools

  • Take the Quiz
  • Anti-Match Quiz
  • ASVAB Calculator
  • Pay
  • Pay Value
  • Bonuses
  • Advancement

Life in the Navy

  • Duty Stations
  • Family Impact
  • Free Degree
  • Be an Officer
  • Recruiters

About

  • About
  • Contact
  • Changelog
  • Donate
  • Privacy
  • Disclaimer
  • Sitemap

Not affiliated with the U.S. Navy or Department of Defense.·© 2026 myNavyRates.org. All rights reserved.

HomeCompare RatesQuizBonusesASVAB CalculatorMore